skip to content »

hhaje.pan-yanino.ru

Radiocarbon dating wrong

The end of this developmental series is firmly tied to similar examples from Lachish Fosse Temple IFigure 13 is a water jar decorated with painted stripes.

radiocarbon dating wrong-4radiocarbon dating wrong-75radiocarbon dating wrong-78

This was exactly my contention; I am glad that he agrees with me on this point! Here, Bienkowski is falling into the same trap as Kenyon—he is using unstratified tomb pottery to date a stratified occupational deposit!Late Bronze Age pottery excavated by Kathleen Kenyon. It has a rim diameter of about 5.1 inches compared to 6.1 inches for our figure 8, while its maximum body diameter is 10.6 inches compared to 16.5 inches.These are two completely different types of vessels with differing modes of typological develop­ment.The Jericho store jar can be compared with Late Bronze I examples from Lachish Fosse Temple I, Figures 10, 11 and 12 are round-bottomed, everted-rim cooking pots.Figure 10 simply shows the continuation of the simple everted rim which had its beginnings in the Middle Bronze period.To begin with, it is important to recog­nize that the pottery of the Late Bronze I period is very similar to that of the final phase of the Middle Bronze period. It is one of "only two forms" for which I cited parallels in the article. A semipopular journal such as BAR in not the place to enter into a detailed discussion of Late Bronze I pottery.

In fact, the material culture of the Late Bronze I period is simply a continuation of that of the Middle Bronze period. Bienkowski dismisses the cited Late Bronze I parallels from Ashdod and Hazor by stating that an "attempt to achieve a precise dating by parallels from such a distance is unconvinc­ing." This is a desperate attempt to discount this telling evidence.

Commercial relations, trade patterns and the types of ceramic wares in use would not necessarily be the same in the two periods. But during this history, changes were taking place.

Be that as it may, it is simply poor metho­dology to base dating almost exclusively on the lack of imported pottery. In the Middle Bronze period, the bowl had a pronounced crimp at the point of carination.

Bryant Wood published his well known article in Biblical Archaeology Review (BAR) on the destruction of Jericho and its correlation with the Biblical account. 1990 issue of BAR, Piotr Bienkowski wrote an article disputing Dr. The following article engages with Bienkowski's criticisms, providing the reader with an in-depth analysis of some of the work done at Jericho, and demonstrating Dr.

Wood's expertise and thorough familiarity with the evidence. The events de­scribed in Judges 3 did not enter into my discussion at all.

Parallels in Late Bronze I are found in Lachish Fosse Temple I, Figure 11 is significant because it shows the widened rim flange which developed in the course of the Late Bronze I period.